Creepy choices: 100 Halloween would you rather questions

Channel the spooky spirit of Halloween with these thrilling and chilling Halloween would you rather questions.

Halloween is a frighteningly fun time: when food and fun blend together (as these Halloween appetizers, Halloween desserts and Halloween dates can attest to).

And should you find yourself in the frankly unlikely situation of not having anything to do come Halloween season, it’s a time when you can ask fun questions that reveal more about friends and family than you knew before, with these Halloween would you rather questions.

Would you rather is a fun game that presents you with two choices that are fairly similar. These ones all come with a Halloween twist!

You can take turns asking each other or have a designated person asking the questions.

These Halloween would you rather questions are designed to be scary, eerie, and generally suitable for all ages so the whole family can get in on the fun.

Halloween would you rather questions

1. Would you rather spend a night in a haunted house or lost in a spooky forest?
2. Would you rather be a vampire or a werewolf for Halloween?
3. Would you rather walk through a graveyard at midnight or spend an hour in a haunted asylum?
4. Would you rather carve pumpkins or make Halloween cookies?
5. Would you rather be chased by a zombie or be followed by a ghost?
6. Would you rather go to a real haunted house or attend a Halloween theme park event?
7. Would you rather have to eat only candy corn for a day or have no candy at all on Halloween?
8. Would you rather meet a friendly ghost or a benign witch?
9. Would you rather spend Halloween night watching horror movies or reading scary stories?
10. Would you rather have a bat as a pet or a black cat?
11. Would you rather have Halloween candy magically refilling in your bowl or your decorations set up by themselves?
12. Would you rather go trick-or-treating in a creepy neighborhood or attend a spooky Halloween party?
13. Would you rather be able to fly on a broomstick or cast real spells?
14. Would you rather have the ability to shape-shift into any Halloween creature or be immortal like a vampire?
15. Would you rather be part of a zombie apocalypse survival team or a ghost hunting squad?
16. Would you rather have a Halloween where every costume you wear becomes real for the night or have the power to turn invisible?
17. Would you rather live in a world where Halloween is every day or only once every four years?
18. Would you rather have a jack-o’-lantern that grants wishes or a magic mirror that answers all your spooky questions?
19. Would you rather have a spooky but harmless ghost living in your house or have to live in a house next to a haunted graveyard?
20. Would you rather spend Halloween in Salem, Massachusetts, or in Transylvania, Romania?
21. Would you rather get lost in a corn maze at night or be locked in a dark pumpkin patch?
22. Would you rather have your house egged by trick-or-treaters or TP’d (toilet-papered)?
23. Would you rather be a part of the Addams Family or the Munsters for a day?
24. Would you rather have to sleep in a coffin for one night or spend the night in a haunted cemetery?
25. Would you rather be cursed to turn into a frog every night or be followed by spiders wherever you go?
26. Would you rather have to watch only scary movies for a month or have to dress in Halloween costumes every day for a month?
27. Would you rather be able to talk to ghosts or be able to see through walls?
28. Would you rather have a never-ending bag of Halloween candy or a magic potion that ensures you always have a great Halloween?
29. Would you rather have to wear a pumpkin on your head for the entire Halloween day or have your feet turn into giant pumpkins?
30. Would you rather have your house be known as the scariest on the block or the most candy-giving?
31. Would you rather be a ghost hunter or a witch/wizard for a profession?
32. Would you rather have a permanent vampire fangs or permanent werewolf claws?
33. Would you rather have a potion that makes you invisible or one that makes you fly?
34. Would you rather have to give out only healthy treats to trick-or-treaters or receive only healthy treats when trick-or-treating?
35. Would you rather have your Halloween costume be extremely scary or absolutely hilarious?
36. Would you rather have to watch horror movies all night on Halloween or have to tell ghost stories all night?
37. Would you rather always have to dress as something cute for Halloween or always as something scary?
38. Would you rather spend the night at Dracula’s Castle or the Bates Motel?
39. Would you rather have an actual witch’s powers for a day or be immune to all forms of witchcraft forever?
40. Would you rather be stuck in a room full of spiders or a room full of snakes on Halloween night?
41. Would you rather have to eat a bowl of real worms or have to sleep in a coffin with fake ones?
42. Would you rather have a zombie apocalypse start on Halloween or an alien invasion?
43. Would you rather be part of a haunted hayride or a haunted house attraction?
44. Would you rather have your Halloween costumes be only homemade or only store-bought forever?
45. Would you rather have a swarm of bats in your house or a mix of black cats and crows?
46. Would you rather walk through a dark forest filled with fog or a deserted, eerie town at night?
47. Would you rather hand out candy to trick-or-treaters or go trick-or-treating yourself?
48. Would you rather have a pet werewolf or a pet zombie?
49. Would you rather be trapped in a horror movie of your choice or in a random horror movie?
50. Would you rather have the headless horseman chase you or be chased by Freddy Krueger?
51. Would you rather be able to turn into a bat or a black cat at will?
52. Would you rather have your house be a stop on a ghost tour or be known for the best Halloween decorations in town?
53. Would you rather go on a date with a vampire or a werewolf?
54. Would you rather get lost in a haunted maze or in an enchanted forest?
55. Would you rather have the ability to speak to spirits or have spirits able to speak to you whenever they want?
56. Would you rather have a spell put on you for good luck or receive a haunted amulet that brings bad luck?
57. Would you rather find out your house is built on an ancient burial ground or that it’s the site of a famous historical tragedy?
58. Would you rather wear a costume that is incredibly detailed and accurate or one that is super comfortable and easy to wear?
59. Would you rather have Halloween-themed music stuck in your head all year round or only be able to watch horror movies for entertainment?
60. Would you rather be able to speak with mythical creatures from folklore or have the knowledge of all ancient and magical herbs?
61. Would you rather live in a world where Halloween legends are real or in a world where every day is Halloween but with no supernatural elements?
62. Would you rather be able to conjure and play with ghostly fire or have the power to freeze anything with a touch on Halloween night?
63. Would you rather have a crystal ball that shows you other worlds or a magic mirror that allows you to visit them?
64. Would you rather be the ruler of a ghostly realm or the guardian of a mystical forest?
65. Would you rather have the power to turn into a swarm of bats or a pack of wolves on Halloween night?
66. Would you rather have to dress up as the same costume every Halloween or have your costume randomly chosen each year?
67. Would you rather be an expert in potions and spells or be able to communicate with mythical creatures?
68. Would you rather visit the hotel from “The Shining” or the house from “The Amityville Horror”?
69. Would you rather have your Halloween candy turn into real monsters or have all your decorations come to life?
70. Would you rather be able to summon a ghostly orchestra or have a chorus of haunted paintings sing for you?
71. Would you rather have a third eye that sees ghosts or have the power to banish spirits?
72. Would you rather win a costume contest or win a haunted house escape game?
73. Would you rather be cursed to turn into a pumpkin at midnight every Halloween or become invisible during the entire day?
74. Would you rather be able to summon and command a legion of bats or be able to turn into mist at will?
75. Would you rather help solve a century-old mystery in a haunted mansion or uncover hidden treasures in an ancient crypt?
76. Would you rather have a friendly goblin as your sidekick on Halloween or a phantom horse as your mode of transport?
77. Would you rather be granted three wishes by a tricky genie on Halloween or find a magical lamp that brings good luck?
78. Would you rather have vampire-like immortality or the ability to shapeshift into animals?
79. Would you rather be haunted by a lost soul or be constantly watched by an unknown entity?
80. Would you rather be able to summon friendly spirits to do your bidding or have the power to change your appearance at will?
81. Would you rather spend a night locked in a room with a friendly poltergeist or dine in a hall with animated suits of armor?
82. Would you rather be able to create an incredibly realistic costume illusion of any character you choose or have your decorations come to life?
83. Would you rather spend the night in the Paris Catacombs or in the Tower of London?
84. Would you rather have a zombie apocalypse break out on Halloween or an alien invasion occur?
85. Would you rather have to survive a night in a haunted house or try to escape from a real-life zombie maze?
86. Would you rather have your house turn into a haunted mansion every Halloween or have it teleport to a random spooky location each year?
87. Would you rather take a potion that gives you night vision on Halloween or one that allows you to hear ghostly whispers?
88. Would you rather turn into a black cat or a carved pumpkin for All Hallows’ Eve?
89. Would you rather take a potion that gives you night vision on Halloween or one that allows you to hear ghostly whispers?
90. Would you rather be haunted by the ghost of Edgar Allan Poe or Stephen King tell you bedtime stories every night?
91. Would you rather have to escape a maze filled with classic movie monsters or an escape room filled with creatures from your worst nightmares?
92. Would you rather have your shadow take on a life of its own on Halloween or your reflection start acting independently?
93. Would you rather be cursed to speak in verses like a witch’s incantation or only communicate through charades on Halloween?
94. Would you rather have a Halloween where every pumpkin you carve comes to life or where every costume you wear gives you the abilities of that character?
95. Would you rather explore an abandoned asylum or a deserted old prison at night?
96. Would you rather go on a haunted hayride or participate in a séance?
97. Would you rather have to survive a slasher movie scenario or a psychological horror situation?
98. Would you rather have a Halloween-themed wedding or a Halloween-themed birthday every year?
99. Would you rather be part of the Scooby-Doo gang or be a Ghostbuster?
100. Would you rather have a jack-o’-lantern that grants wishes or a magic mirror that answers all your spooky questions?

These Halloween would you rather questions are designed to make your Halloween frightfully delightful.

Whether you’re chuckling over these spooky scenarios or getting a little scared, these questions will bring an extra thrill to your Halloween.

So gather your friends, light the jack-o’-lanterns, and let the spooktacular fun begin.

Love Halloween? Check out all things Halloween for Halloween food, activities and more.